Chicago’s best draft round across eleven drafts was the fifth, where the Bears hit on 10 of 11 picks. Across the complete classes from 2012 through 2022, that is a 500-snap hit rate of 90.9 percent against a league mark of 45.7. It is a better rate than their own first round, where they went 7 of 8.

The story of the Bears’ decade is usually told from the top of the board. Ryan Pace traded up one spot to take Mitchell Trubisky second overall in 2017. He sent the 2019 and 2020 first-round picks to Oakland for Khalil Mack, then sent the 2022 first to the Giants to move up for Justin Fields. Ryan Poles took Caleb Williams first overall in 2024. Nearly every argument about whether Chicago can draft has been an argument about those four decisions.

The record says the argument is pointed at the wrong part of the weekend. Chicago’s overall hit rate in the window is 55.8 percent, 43 of 77, a shade under the league’s 57.3. Take the fifth round out and the Bears are 33 of 66, exactly 50.0 percent, against a league rate of 59.2 in the same six rounds. One round of Saturday afternoon picks is the difference between a slightly below-average drafting franchise and a badly below-average one.

The rounds everyone argued about

The first round in Chicago is a story about quarterbacks, and by this series’ measure the quarterbacks cleared the bar. Trubisky has 3,956 career snaps with a best season of 942. Fields has 3,291 with a best of 917. Both count as hits, and neither is still a Bear, which is the clearest illustration of how little the 500-snap line says about a franchise pick. Any quarterback handed the job for a season clears it, whatever happens after.

The rest of the first round mostly did what first rounds do. Kyle Long went 20th in 2013 and peaked at 1,148 snaps in a season. Leonard Floyd went ninth in 2016 and has played 153 games. Roquan Smith went eighth in 2018 and has 8,250 career snaps. The one miss is the one Bears fans remember. Kevin White went seventh in 2015, a receiver taken to be the next piece of the offense, and finished with 764 career snaps and a best season of 194. He never got close.

Seven of eight sounds strong until it is set beside the league, where first-round picks hit at 94.0 percent. Chicago also made only eight first-round picks in eleven drafts, because three of them were traded away for Mack and Fields. The second round was steadier: 11 of 13, 84.6 percent against a league rate of 83.1. Day 1 and Day 2 combined came in at 77.8 percent against a league 82.0, which is close enough to par that the top of the board cannot explain much in either direction. The explanation sits further down.

The middle of the board gave way

The rounds immediately after the expensive ones are where Chicago’s record actually sags. The Bears went 3 of 6 in the third round, against a league rate of 71.0 percent. They went 5 of 12 in the fourth, 41.7 percent against a league 62.0. Across those two rounds that is 8 hits on 18 picks, in exactly the range where most teams find their second wave of starters.

The 2019 class is the cleanest example of what that looks like. With no first-round pick and no second, Chicago made five selections and hit on one: David Montgomery, taken 73rd, who played 105 games and peaked at 761 snaps. The class rate was 20.0 percent in a year the league converted 58.3. It was the worst draft of the window in Chicago by a wide margin.

It would be easy to read the fifth-round number as part of a broader Day 3 skill, the kind this series found in Baltimore in September, where the edge was spread across the late rounds. Chicago’s is not. Strip the fifth round out of Day 3 and the Bears went 12 of 39 across rounds four, six and seven, 30.8 percent against a league rate of 39.6. The sixth round was the worst of them at 3 of 14, 21.4 percent against a league 33.6. The seventh, at 4 of 13, was the only other late round where Chicago beat the league, and it beat a 23.8 percent mark by roughly one pick. The skill, if it is one, lives in a single round.

Eleven picks in the fifth

The best value in the round is also the best argument for it. Adrian Amos, taken 142nd in 2015, has played ten seasons, 143 games and 9,112 career snaps. That is more career snaps than Roquan Smith, the eighth overall pick three years later. A fifth-round safety outlasting a top-ten linebacker on the field is the whole argument of this piece in one comparison, and the rest of the list is short enough to show in full.

YearPickPlayerPosHitBest season (snaps)
2013163Jordan MillsTyes1,104
2015142Adrian AmosSyes1,196
2016150Jordan HowardRByes658
2017147Jordan MorganGno0
2018145Bilal NicholsDTyes884
2020155Trevis GipsonDEyes732
2020163Kindle VildorCByes944
2020173Darnell MooneyWRyes989
2021151Larry BoromOLyes726
2022168Braxton JonesOLyes1,095
2022174Dominique RobinsonDEyes654

The deepest single weekend came in 2020. Chicago made three fifth-round selections that spring and all three became 500-snap players: Trevis Gipson at 155, Kindle Vildor at 163 and Darnell Mooney at 173. Mooney, the last of them, has played 91 games and 5,204 career snaps, with 989 in his best season, which is the workload of a starting receiver. The league converted 12 of 33 fifth-round picks that year, 36.4 percent. Chicago converted three of three.

None of these were headline picks. A fifth-round corner does not lead the draft-night coverage, and none of these names arrived carrying the expectations attached to Trubisky or White. That is the uncomfortable part of the record. The players who held up Chicago’s draft numbers were the ones the franchise was least judged on.

The rest of the list fills out a pattern that runs across the decade. Jordan Mills went 163rd in 2013 and played ten seasons at tackle, 5,938 snaps in all. Bilal Nichols went 145th in 2018 and played 104 games on the defensive line. Braxton Jones went 168th in 2022 and played 1,095 snaps at tackle in his best season, a full year of work from a pick most teams spend on a special-teams body.

The one miss is a reminder of what the round normally looks like. Jordan Morgan, a guard taken 147th in 2017, never played a regular-season snap. Around the league, missing is the common outcome for a fifth-round pick, not the exception: fewer than half of them reach 500 snaps in any season. Chicago had it happen once in eleven tries.

A habit that outlived three general managers

The streak is not the work of one front office. Phil Emery made one fifth-round pick in his three drafts and it hit. Ryan Pace made eight in his seven drafts and seven hit. Poles made two in his first class and both hit. Three regimes, three scouting departments, one round that kept working.

Most of the volume, though, is Pace’s, and it changes how his tenure reads. Pace’s overall rate across the 2015 through 2021 drafts was 58.7 percent, 27 of 46, against a league mark of 58.1 for those years. That is the one Bears regime in the window that drafted slightly better than the league. Take his eight fifth-round picks away and the rest went 20 of 38, 52.6 percent, against his overall 58.7. The general manager remembered for Trubisky and the Mack trade did some of his best work in the rounds nobody remembers him for.

Emery’s three classes landed exactly on the league line: 11 of 20, 55.0 percent, in a span when the league also converted 55.0. Poles has only one complete class in the window, and it went 5 of 11, 45.5 percent against a league 58.4 in 2022. Two of those five hits came out of the fifth round. Whether the habit survives him is still open, because his three classes since are too young to grade.

Where the fifth-rounders went

The fifth round produced the hits and almost none of them stayed. Of the ten fifth-round picks who cleared the bar, two are on the 2025 roster: Braxton Jones and Dominique Robinson, both from the 2022 class. Amos, Mooney, Mills, Nichols and the rest of the 2020 trio are gone.

That fits the rest of the Chicago picture. Of the 77 picks the Bears made from 2012 through 2022, seven were on the 2025 roster. Pace’s 46 picks left two behind, Cole Kmet and Jaylon Johnson, both second-rounders from 2020. Emery’s 20 left none. The series’ cross-team retention measure asks how many of a team’s hits from the 2017 through 2021 classes are still on the roster, and Chicago kept 2 of 17, 11.8 percent, 29th of 32 against a league mark of 21.3.

The roster that took the field in 2025 is overwhelmingly a Poles roster. Twenty-four of the 26 homegrown players came from his four drafts. The fifth-round talent Chicago found for most of a decade was developed, played, and then let go, and the franchise rebuilt the roster around a new set of first-round picks: Darnell Wright, Rome Odunze, Colston Loveland and Williams.

Why the fifth round may be flattering Chicago

The threshold rewards opportunity as much as evaluation, and that is the first problem with this finding. A hit means 500 snaps in a season, and a fifth-round pick on a thin roster gets snaps because nobody better is standing in front of him. Chicago spent much of the window rebuilding, and a fifth-rounder on a rebuilding depth chart has more room to earn snaps than one on a contender. Vildor’s 944-snap season and Gipson’s 732 are real workloads, but a contender with a full secondary and edge rotation might never have handed them out. Part of what reads as a scouting edge may be a roster that was easy to crack.

The second problem is size. Eleven picks is a sample, not a system, and one result moves the rate by roughly nine points. Three of the ten hits came from the 2020 class alone, so a single strong weekend accounts for nearly a third of the record. The hits also lean toward positions that play a lot of snaps: three offensive linemen, a safety and a corner make up half the list, while the one running back on it, Jordan Howard, cleared the line with 658 snaps in his best season. Howard cleared the bar by 158 snaps. Three near-misses like that, at positions that play fewer snaps, would turn 10 of 11 into 7 of 11, 63.6 percent: still well above the league, but a good round rather than a freak one.

Neither objection erases the gap. A rate twice the league’s, sustained across three general managers and eight separate classes, is hard to produce by roster weakness alone, since every rebuilding team has thin depth charts and the league still converted 45.7 percent. What the number supports is narrower: Chicago’s fifth-round picks became regular players far more often than the league’s, not that they became good ones.

What it means

Chicago spent the decade arguing about first-round quarterbacks and trading away first-round picks, and the part of its draft record that actually stood out came on the third day. Without the fifth round, the Bears were a 50 percent drafter in a 59 percent league. With it, they were nearly average.

That is a fragile thing to depend on. A front office cannot plan to hit ten of eleven picks in any round, and a Poles roster now built around Williams and three other recent first-rounders will have fewer open snaps for a fifth-rounder to claim. If the round keeps working on a roster that no longer needs it to, Chicago has found something real. If it stops, the decade will look like what it mostly was: a team that drafted its middle rounds poorly and got lucky late.